1v1 Institutional Counterparty Comparison
CommSec vs IB: Regulation, 6D Ratings & Safety Audit
Deterministic head-to-head benchmarking of CommSec (Commonwealth Securities Limited) and IB (Interactive Brokers Hong Kong Limited) across primary regulatory filings, statutory Tier-1 authorisations, 6-Dimension compliance scores, execution software, and warning exposure.
Coverage: Stock brokers, investment platforms and wealth managers
- CommSec 6D Score
- 6.5
- IB 6D Score
- 8.0
- Regulated Licences
- 1 vs 5
- Warning Flags
- 0 vs 0
IB outranks CommSec by +1.5 pts in composite 6D scoring (8.0 vs 6.5)
On supervisory breadth, CommSec holds 1 active regulated licence(s) (0 Tier-1) out of 1 total filings and 0 warning count(s), whereas IB holds 5 active regulated licence(s) (0 Tier-1) out of 5 total filings and 0 warning count(s). Allocators should inspect the individual licence numbers and contracting legal entities below before onboarding.
6-Dimension Quantitative Scorecard Comparison
Head-to-head breakdown across all 6 proprietary evaluation dimensions (0.0–10.0 scale).
| Evaluation Dimension | Methodology Weight | CommSec | IB | Score Delta | Dimension Leader |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Composite 6D Score | 100% Composite | 6.5 | 8.0 | +1.5 | IB |
| Regulatory & Licensing Integrity (riskScore) | 30% Weight | 6.5 | 8.0 | +1.5 | IB |
| Execution & Software Infrastructure (industryScore) | 20% Weight | 4.0 | 6.0 | +2.0 | IB |
| User Reputation & Complaint Telemetry (userScore) | 20% Weight | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | Statistical Tie |
| Institutional Brand Longevity (brandScore) | 15% Weight | 6.5 | 8.0 | +1.5 | IB |
| Global Market Influence & Footprint (influenceScore) | 15% Weight | 6.5 | 8.0 | +1.5 | IB |
Visual Architecture Benchmark: CommSec vs IB
Vector comparison exhibit generated from live supervisory snapshot metrics.
Regulatory Standing, Entity & Platform Comparison
Structural comparison of supervisory authorisations, domicile, execution terminals, and risk telemetry.
| Audit Attribute | CommSec | IB |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Legal Name | Commonwealth Securities Limited | Interactive Brokers Hong Kong Limited |
| Source Risk Classification | Risk level not supplied | Risk level not supplied |
| Active Regulated / Total Filings | 1 regulated / 1 total (0 Tier-1) | 5 regulated / 5 total (0 Tier-1) |
| Recorded Certificate Numbers | ||
| Registered Domicile / Address | Commonwealth Bank Place South' Level 1, 11 Harbour Street, SYDNEY NSW 2000 Commonwealth Securities Locked Bag 22 Australia Square NSW 1215 | One Pickwick Plaza, Greenwich, CT 06830 USA |
| Offered Asset Classes & Services | Australian shares, margin loans, cash, options, ETFs, warrants, fixed income securities, international shares | Stocks, options, futures, currencies, securities, etc. |
| Execution Software & Terminals | Proprietary / Web Platform | MT4, MT5 |
| Supported Client Languages | English | Chinese (Simplified), Chinese (Traditional), Spanish, Portuguese, English |
| Warning / Exposure Count | 0 recorded warning(s) | 0 recorded warning(s) |
| Specialized Sub-Page Audits |
Related 1v1 Institutional Comparisons
Compare CommSec and IB against other regulated peers in our stock brokers, investment platforms and wealth managers slice.
Frequently Asked Questions: CommSec vs IB
Deterministic counterparty comparison answers derived from supervisory records.
Which institution has stronger regulatory oversight: CommSec or IB?
IB holds more active regulated filings (5 vs 1). Specifically, CommSec maintains 1 total recorded filing(s) (ASIC) with 0 warning flag(s), whereas IB maintains 5 recorded filing(s) (IIROC, Financial Conduct Authority, ASIC, MAS) with 0 warning flag(s). Always confirm the specific subsidiary onboarding your account on the official regulator register.
How do the 6D quantitative compliance scores compare between CommSec and IB?
In ETFYield Lab's 6-Dimension scoring matrix (0.0–10.0 scale), CommSec records an Overall Score of 6.5 (Risk & Licensing: 6.5, Brand: 6.5, Market Influence: 6.5, User Reputation: 0.0, Execution & Software: 4.0), compared with IB at 8.0 Overall (Risk & Licensing: 8.0, Brand: 8.0, Market Influence: 8.0, User Reputation: 0.0, Execution & Software: 6.0).
How do CommSec and IB differ in trading platforms and asset classes?
CommSec lists Australian shares, margin loans, cash, options, ETFs, warrants, fixed income securities, international shares with execution software [proprietary/web execution], while IB lists Stocks, options, futures, currencies, securities, etc. with execution software [MT4, MT5]. Counterparties should verify FIX/API connectivity, server routing topology, and negative balance protection per entity.
Which counterparty carries lower regulatory warning and complaint exposure: CommSec or IB?
CommSec carries a "Risk level not supplied" classification with 0 warning/exposure count(s) and 0 user comment(s), while IB carries a "Risk level not supplied" classification with 0 warning/exposure count(s) and 0 user comment(s).
Structured against supervisory register snapshots and public regulatory filings. Verify your contracting legal entity and current authorisation status directly on the issuing regulator’s official register before transacting.